Most of us learn golf as stroke play, counting every shot and adding them up at the end, because that is what the professionals do on television. It is also the most punishing way to play the game, and the least suited to a beginner. Golf has a whole shelf of other formats, most of them older than stroke play, and many of them kinder. Knowing them makes a casual round more fun, makes a club competition less frightening, and makes it possible for four people of wildly different ability to play together and all have a stake in the outcome.
Table of Contents
Stroke play: the honest total
Stroke play is the format of the scorecard. Every stroke counts, every hole is completed, and the lowest total wins. With handicaps, you subtract your course handicap from your gross score to get a net score, and net scores are compared. It is the fairest measure of a whole round and the best way to build a handicap, because every score gets posted.
Its weakness is that one bad hole ruins the day. A ten on the fourth cannot be undone by fourteen good holes. For a beginner, that is exhausting. It is also slow, because every ball must be holed out, including the fourth putt. Many clubs soften it by setting a maximum score per hole, often net double bogey, so that a disaster costs something but does not swallow the round.
Match play: hole by hole
Match play is the older format. Two sides play against each other hole by hole, and the side with the lower score on a hole wins that hole. The match is decided by holes won, not strokes taken. A scoreline of “three and two” means one side was three holes up with two to play, so the match ended on the sixteenth green.
The joy of match play is that a bad hole costs exactly one hole. A ten and a five are the same loss. You can pick up your ball once the hole is gone, which speeds things up, and you can concede a short putt to your opponent, which is a small act of civility that shapes the whole atmosphere of the game. With handicaps, the higher-handicap player receives the difference between the two course handicaps, applied on the holes with the lowest stroke index. It is the format we would recommend for any beginner playing a better friend, because the beginner can lose eleven holes and still walk off feeling that the three they won were real victories.
Stableford: points for good holes
Stableford scoring was devised by an English doctor and first used in a club competition in 1932, and it remains the most popular competition format at ordinary clubs across Britain, Ireland and Australia, and increasingly in Canada. Instead of counting strokes, you earn points on each hole based on your net score. A net double bogey or worse earns nothing, a net bogey earns one point, net par earns two, net birdie three, net eagle four. The highest total wins, and 36 points means you played exactly to your handicap.
The genius of it is what happens on a bad hole. Once you cannot score a point, you pick up and walk to the next tee. There is no nine, no ten, no walk of shame. The round moves faster, the mood stays lighter, and the scoring rewards a player who makes a handful of pars over one who plods steadily along. For beginners, it is the format that most quickly makes competition enjoyable. Some clubs use a modified version with bigger swings, awarding several points for birdies and taking points away for double bogeys, which favours the bold.
Team formats that hide our weaknesses
Golf’s team games are where mixed-ability groups shine, and the names can be confusing. A short glossary of the common ones:
- Scramble. Everyone in the team hits, the team picks the best ball, everyone plays from that spot, and so on until the ball is holed. A beginner contributes a good putt or a lucky drive and is never exposed. This is the format of charity days and office outings, and the reason they finish in four hours despite the lack of skill on display.
- Best ball, also called four-ball. Each player plays their own ball; the lower score of the two partners counts on each hole. Everyone plays real golf, but a bad hole is covered by a partner.
- Foursomes, or alternate shot. Two partners share one ball and hit it in turn, alternating tee shots. It is fast, sociable and unforgiving: your partner has to play from wherever you put it. The famous team matches between Europe and the United States use both this and four-ball.
- Greensomes. Both partners drive, choose the better drive, and alternate from there. A gentler cousin of foursomes.
- Skins. Each hole is worth a prize; tie a hole and the prize carries over to the next. Best played for pride or coffee rather than money.
Picking the right one on the day
The choice depends on who is playing and why. Four friends of similar ability who want a proper contest: stroke play or Stableford, with handicaps. Two people of very different ability: match play with the full handicap difference. A group where two people have never played: a scramble, so that everyone contributes and nobody holds the group up. A busy course on a Saturday: Stableford or match play, because both let you pick up when a hole is lost, and the group behind will thank you.
One practical warning. If you want the round to count for your handicap, the format matters. Stroke play and Stableford rounds can be posted; the score is recorded hole by hole with the maximum applied. Match play rounds can usually be posted too, provided you record a most-likely score for holes that were conceded. Scrambles and other team formats where you did not play your own ball cannot be posted at all, and nobody expects them to be.
The wider point is that golf was never designed as a solitary accounting exercise. It began as a game between two people on a stretch of common ground, decided hole by hole, and it still works best when it is played that way: against someone, for something small, with the freedom to pick up and laugh when a hole goes wrong.
